Hacker News
points by defrost 1 hour ago | 0 comments
> people who are ready to surrender don't need to be nuked twice.

The question remains whether in fact Japan "needed" to be nuked even once - it's unknown whether the ongoing city by city destruction would have resolved WWII.

Further, did they "need" to be nuked a second time so quickly (within three days)? That second nuke was not to force a surrender (just as the first wasn't) - the two bombings were two live tests of two separate weapon designs untested in the field of war.

[–] CamperBob2 52 minutes ago
Further, did they "need" to be nuked a second time so quickly (within three days)?

Apparently so. Most people will run up the white flag after being nuked once, you see.

It was important to make them think that we had a whole stockpile of them. Otherwise, twice might not have been enough.

Hacker News