Hacker News
points by smodo 2 days ago | 0 comments
Kagi is really good. And I never thought I would say this but their AI assistent actually works. It is well integrated with their search product to deliver actually usefully results.

That said I’ve had a hard time getting other people on board. Apparently many people are just numb to the enshittification of the web?

[–] fl4regun 2 days ago
I think Kagi is a cool idea but I just don't have a strong usecase for it. I don't find myself googling things as much as I used to, and if anything, when I am googling things they just aren't that important. I end up going directly to certain websites instead.
[–] pedro_caetano 2 days ago
The biggest value for me is:

- Really high SNR when searching about topics I am not a subject matter expert on.

- Really good at finding prior art on a topic while not necessarily limited to papers conferences and patents (e.g. finding obscure blog posts on a hobby project that actually is relevant prior work).

Arguably this can be achieved with frontier models but my experience is that Kagi is vastly more exhaustive and well I don't need to ask for references because they are indexed in the search itself.

[–] Zambyte 2 days ago
> I end up going directly to certain websites instead.

Many of my Kagi searches never actually show me a Kagi interface before I get to the page that I want. Many of my search queries are putting something like "jj @gh !" in my browsers URL bar, which will navigate directly to https://github.com/jj-vcs/jj, or "nats @dh !" to navigate to https://hub.docker.com/_/nats/, etc. The ! will navigate directly to the first result, and the @gh will add site:github.com to your query.

[–] ActionHank 2 days ago
Everyone I mentioned it to scoffed at the idea of paying for search.
[–] CSSer 2 days ago
Last night at a social outing I had to explain to a project manager who is supposedly an AI expert that the side project I run as a community resource can't be entirely free because it costs me non-trivial amounts of money due to its success. She was unaware that things like bandwidth, or email, or compute could cost anything. She even asked me what compute is. She even started with "I mean, I know you pay for the domain, but... What else?".

Even people working close to us seem to have no conception of the economics of the web. Kagi is, practically speaking, an activist's service. Most people only respond to direct incentives. It's how we got to where we are now. I would expect this uphill battle almost naturally at this point.

[–] throwaway219450 2 days ago
How many of those people don’t use an ad blocker? I know a lot of people who put up with that web experience, and it boggles the mind. I digress. It’s not as if showing ads has somehow funded a better search experience, if anything ads go up and quality goes down is what I see. I pay for YT Premium. I would also pay for ad-free, more controllable, Google Search.

Maybe it’s a situation where the frog slowly got boiled, or maybe we have rose tinted nostalgia glasses and search is actually better now than it used to be? Even with ad blockers, they’re determined to ram shopping/promoted results into unrelated queries and I’m fed up using verbatim mode. You used to at least get Wiki results fairly high up, no longer it seems. And every software-related search returns GeekForGeeks slop instead of the actual docs. And they wonder why traffic is going to agents?

[–] druskacik 2 days ago
I mean, I think for average internet user the existing free alternatives are more than good enough.
[–] jeremyjh 2 days ago
Every single time I accidentally use Google I am shocked at how terrible it is. People just haven’t seen the alternatives. I finally setup a family subscription to get my wife and kids on Kagi and they don’t want to go back to Google now.
[–] ActionHank 2 days ago
How do you deal with searches for local businesses? I've found these to be a big blind spot vs DDG / Google.
[–] dotancohen 2 days ago
Am I searching for a local business? I go to Google.

Am I searching for the range of input voltages an Arduino can safely handle? Kagi.

[–] mulderc 2 days ago
I don't think I agree with that but I think ads and slop you get from the "free" alternatives are more damaging in subtle ways that people don't appreciate. I also pay to remove ads from just about everything I use and am shocked at just how much better that makes my life.
[–] bdzr 2 days ago
I've found the assistant, particularly the android app, to be buggy as all hell. Perhaps it's fine in the browser but as a heavy phone user I couldn't make it work anymore.
[–] khaleel-kagi 2 days ago
Sorry to hear that! Could you please share a bit more about the issues you ran into with the Android app?
[–] mulderc 2 days ago
At least on iOS running the site as a web app works great. Also the iOS app works
[–] neogodless 2 days ago
I recently tried the Android App, and could not get it to function. But Kagi Assistant on Firefox for Android works fine.
[–] khaleel-kagi 2 days ago
Can you please share a bit more about the issue? a crash or an error? I'd love to understand what wasn't working. Thanks!
[–] neogodless 1 day ago
It just didn't do anything when I hit Enter. I typed in a query, hit Enter, and nothing happened. I gave up after that.