Hacker News
points by fooqux 2 days ago | 0 comments
Sorry, but this just seems like FUD to me.

A) This is already the case for basically every phone for sale, and thus isn't really applicable to this article. Also, I thought the modem was by Qualcomm?

B) Sure, they could ban all Chinese made devices but that would basically mean banning all devices. Pixels are made in China just like Motorola, so again, not much of a difference here (I'll allow that there may be a difference of just how much of the phones are made in China.)

C) How is the government going to ban the use of an open source OS? And why would they? Apple has spit in the government's eye a few times and yet they don't ban iOS.

[–] Rooster61 2 days ago
Not intended to be FUD, legitimate concern. I could see how it could come off that way.

A and B) Sure, but you said it yourself: that how much is a significant factor. And Pixels use Samsung modems, not Qualcomm

C) How does the government ban anything? Through legislation and enforcement. That can take a number of different forms

[–] fooqux 2 days ago
> And Pixels use Samsung modems, not Qualcomm

Yeah and Samsung foundry makes Qualcomm chips. So does TSMC, but I'm pretty sure China doesn't control that despite what they may say. At no point while searching online did I see mention of these chips being made in China.

> Not intended to be FUD, legitimate concern. I could see how it could come off that way.

No problem!