Hacker News
points by __MatrixMan__ 2 days ago | 0 comments
A few years back I un-bashed my life as much as possible in favor of nushell (though it's not the only shell to encourage structure). I feel like it has really helped me notice a lot of this-needs-more-structure type problems outside of my shell that I otherwise wouldn't have.

The elegance of the unix-y approach is actually that it's all bits. You can just join things together and shove the bits through, that's a wild simplification compared with having vendor-specific kinds of plugs. But we could have that kind of compatibility while also benefiting from structure.

So I encourage everybody to give a shell with structured output a try, let it rewire your brain, and then ask yourself: how is the OS holding this back from being everything it could be? Because if we build that OS, it won't encourage these problems.

When I imagine it, it would probe either side of a pipe to see if they support negotiation. If not, send the bits through in the same old unixy way. If so, use the newest schema for structured data that is supported by both sides.

[–] jonhohle 2 days ago
At Amazon we had RecordStream which implemented most of the standard Unix tools on structured streams. It was pretty easy to write filters, aggregators, and formatted output in something not much more complicated than sed/awk/cut/join/sort pipelines. There was a convenient structured log format for services that was often used as input.

https://github.com/benbernard/RecordStream

[–] hedora 2 days ago
That looks really cool. I've been heading the opposite direction: posix shell for everything.

I have a bunch of management scripts, etc, that need to run on everything from a potato to a T-1000, and that's the only language that's always available. (OpenBSD sh, FreeBSD sh, busybox, bash, dash, zsh all can cope with it).

I'd love something that's at least JSON-typed (or equivalent), but that can be bootstrapped up on least-common-denominator posix.

Has anyone built something similar? (Yes, I'm being picky -- bun / ts is already a pretty low bar for cross platform support, but these scripts do stuff like install node, so I'm not totally crazy for asking.)

[–] cowlevel 2 days ago
Python?
[–] hedora 1 day ago
Not installed universally, and it also doesn't reliably run python programs. (Minor + major semver changes break backwards compatibility, and pip mutates the global system state.)