Hacker News
points by eqvinox 2 days ago | 0 comments
> DNSSEC failures need to be louder.

Full ACK. As a part of this, DNSsec validation needs to be as close to the client app as possible and reasonable; definitely never off-host. (Caches can do additional validation, but that makes the error reporting complicated.)

corollary: the AD bit should never be relied on on anything actually on the network. Maybe on localhost, but even there it's questionable in UX results.

[–] cowlevel 2 days ago
It's about time to question the whole off-host DNS resolver thing entirely. Fine if you want to have a cache, but the cache should return the whole record chain starting from the root in that case, so the client can validate it. Also fine to have an on-host cache that caches validation status.
Hacker News